Summary

Do you have any questions about the Budget? 

  1. Welfare system is 'unsustainable', chancellor sayspublished at 08:36 GMT

    Turning to welfare, Healey says there are two reports out next month which will help map out how the system needs to change in the long run.

    He adds they are reducing the rate of increase in the welfare bill compared to the previous period with a "broken system" from the Tories - citing bringing back face-to-face assessments and changing Universal Credit.

    He says the system currently is "unsustainable" and says he "moral duty" to help young people not in employment, education or training (Neet).

    Asked whether there would be cuts in welfare before the next election, Healey says: "There will be. There will be a reduction in the benefits bill.

    "We'll do that in a Labour way and we'll do that because it is simply not good for Britain or progressive to have a bigger and bigger benefits bill."

  2. Chancellor defends increase in taxes on savings and landlordspublished at 08:29 GMT

    Healey defends his decision to increase taxes on savings and landlords, saying he wanted to protect income that was earned through employment.

    He also says he wanted to relieve the cost of business and the cost of living in the "fairest possible way" by increasing taxes on betting shops.

    He says 70,000 of high street firms - shops, bakeries, cafes, pubs and more - will be relieved of business rates for two years.

    • As a reminder, the chancellor announced yesterday he would increase taxes on gambling machines and exempt vape shops from business rates relief.
    • Landlords also face a tax rise on rental income from 2027, while the rate of tax on income from savings will also rise after yesterday's Budget.
  3. Healey says £100 energy payment will create 'breathing space' for most householdspublished at 08:21 GMT

    Chancellor John Healey speaks to BBC Radio 4

    We can now bring you more details of an interview with Chancellor John Healey that was recorded after the Budget yesterday.

    The chancellor begins by listing the "economic storms" including the Iran war and Russia's invasion of Ukraine.

    He says they are hitting "worldwide" and acknowledges "people are feeling it", adding that they are hitting government costs too.

    On the £100 payment - he says that will be for "most households" and it's a way to get money to people at a time they are facing the early winter bills.

    He says the government cannot completely remove the cost of living pressures but can help where they can to create breathing space - and adds he has asked the banks to help fund that.

    This Flourish post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.

  4. Watch: Chancellor speaks to Today programmepublished at 08:13 GMT

    Chancellor John Healey's interview with BBC Radio 4's Today programme, recorded yesterday, is playing at the top of this page.

    You can follow along by clicking watch live at the top of this page. We'll also bring you key updates here.

  5. Welfare spending projected to rise by nearly £100bn, says OBRpublished at 08:11 GMT

    Dearbail Jordan
    Senior business and economics reporter

    Spending on welfare could rise from £353bn this year to £431bn in 2031-32, according to the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR)

    The official forecaster reckons this will be driven by spending on heath-related state help such as Personal Independence Payments as well as benefits for pensioners.

    It says that spending on welfare - measured as a percentage of the economy - is actually lower than a peak reached in 2012-13 due to rising unemployment in the aftermath of the global financial crisis.

    But current levels are still high and what is different now is the increase in health-related welfare payments in the wake of the Covid pandemic.

    The OBR estimates that welfare spending will increase by £19bn this year, then £16bn a year on average until 2031-32.

  6. Cut welfare and foreign aid - what would the Conservatives do differently?published at 08:00 GMT

    Shadow Chancellor Andrew Griffith speaks to BBC Radio 4

    Griffith is now questioned about Conservative promises to cut taxes and spending should they win the next election.

    He says the party would reinstate the two-child benefit cap, bring back face-to-face assessments for Pip disability allowance - for which "minor conditions such as anxiety will longer qualify", adding that the party had identified £70bn in savings overall.

    Pushed further on what cuts the Conservatives would make, Griffith says "you won't get benefits if you've come from a non-EU country" and you're "not contributing to the economy".

    He adds that the Tories would "reduce overseas spending, reduce the cost of the civil service by about a third", taking it back to 2016 headcount levels.

  7. Lowering fiscal headroom leaves Britain 'more fragile' - shadow chancellorpublished at 07:55 GMT

    Shadow Chancellor Andrew Griffith tells the Today programme there were no cuts to public spending in yesterday's Budget, describing welfare as "the biggest out of control part" of government finances.

    He says the Budget he would have presented would have been "very different in terms of some tougher choices on welfare" and would have "properly funded" the extra money needed for defence.

    He says it would also have dealt with the deficit, adding: "We're borrowing money just to pay the interest on the national debt."

    Asked if he needs to show some humility given the Conservatives' record in office, Griffith says: "I've never shied away from saying previous Conservative governments have had a chequered record on managing the public finances".

    He says Chancellor John Healey has "left us more fragile today in a challenging world because he lowered the [fiscal] headroom".

    • As a reminder, Healey said in his Budget speech yesterday that Britain would have a smaller buffer to meet its fiscal targets, with the government's tax revenues were expected to ⁠be £15 billion higher than day-to-day spending ​in the 2029/30 fiscal year.
  8. Healey ducked big decision on defence spending, shadow chancellor sayspublished at 07:52 GMT

    Shadow chancellor Andrew Griffith speaks to BBC Radio 4's Today programme

    Shadow Chancellor Andrew Griffith has been speaking to BBC Radio 4's Today programme.

    The public finances are "not in good shape", he starts, saying that we live in "very difficult geopolitical times".

    He describes the Budget as "disjointed" and said the chancellor ducked the two biggest decisions yesterday - the first of which was defence.

    Pointing out he resigned as defence secretary over funding, Griffith says a plan to meet 3% GDP on defence by 2030 is "still not funded".

    He stresses this is about "sustainable financing" for the armed forces at a time of increasing global threats.

    He then repeats Badenoch's line from yesterday that Moscow and Tehran will not be worried when we are not taking defence seriously.

  9. When might I start to feel better off?published at 07:48 GMT

    Michael Race
    Business and economics reporter

    After all the policy announcements and political rhetoric being banded about yesterday, you might be wondering this morning: when might I start to feel better off?

    It's a mixed picture when it comes to economic growth in the coming years, with difficult times approaching in the near-term, according to the government's official forecaster the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR).

    The UK's financial watchdog sharply cut its growth expectations for the UK in 2027 as high energy bills hit the spending power of households and business.

    Growth recovers towards the end of the decade, but the longer term picture for the country is one of weakness.

    A graph showing real household disposable income rising over a 10 year periodImage source, OBR

    Delving further into the OBR's report, I came across this chart on real household disposable income, which is an indicator of living standards, over a period of decades.

    It shows that for almost 20 years since the global financial crisis, living standards on average have grown at a much lower than rate they were on average for the latter half of the 20th century.

    Living standards are forecast to dip next year due high energy prices and while they start to rise again as we reach the end of this decade, the growth in living standards is still way below where they were in the early 2000s.

  10. 'Scattergun' Budget did little to address 'sharp challenges' - Resolution Foundationpublished at 07:32 GMT

    Britain's Chancellor of the Exchequer John Healey holds his red dispatch box outside Number 11 Downing StreetImage source, EPA/Shutterstock

    The Resolution Foundation has described Healey's Budget as "scattergun", adding that it did little to address "the sharp challenges facing Britain".

    The economic think tank, which focuses on lower and middle earners, says the cost of living measures announced yesterday would not prevent energy bills from jumping above levels seen during the last energy shock.

    “Cost of living support is being spread far too thinly and will leave even those families receiving help facing higher energy bills than they did during the last energy price shock," Chief Executive Ruth Curtice says.

    The think tank adds that typical annual energy bills are expected to reach £1,750 after Government support in 2026-27, forecasting also that typical disposable income would fall by £1,050 between now and the end of the parliamentary term in 2028-29.

    “A more dramatic change of tactics may be needed, and we did not learn how the Government will choose between public service ambitions and household incomes. Next year the choices will unavoidably get starker," Curtice adds.

  11. Government departments could face spending cuts - OBR chiefpublished at 07:27 GMT

    Asked by the BBC whether the government's spending plans amount to austerity, Prof Jonathan Haskel says "I'll leave others to use those particular words" and that the OBR "just does the mathematics".

    But he did say that if the government keeps the commitments it has made in defence, education and health, there could be a cut by 2.6% in other government departments.

    On welfare, he also clarifies this would rise from around 10.5% to 11.5% of GDP - a large chunk being for disability and pension payments, which have grown in recent years.

    Overall, he says the economic outlook was a "pretty grim picture", suggesting forecasting has been tricky over the past three years as the government hasn't made detailed spending plans.

  12. Cost of borrowing has increased 'very severely', says OBR chiefpublished at 07:23 GMT

    OBR chair Jonathan Haskel speaks to BBC Radio 4

    Chair of the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) Jonathan Haskel is speaking to BBC Radio 4's Today programme.

    He explains borrowing rates that the chancellor faces have gone up "very severely" since the OBR's last forecast in March - with a £14bn increase in the borrowing bill just from an increase in interest rates alone.

    The chancellor had to address that before deciding on any policies - for context, the figure is around one third of the entire budget for the Department for Transport, he says.

    He explains that in the OBR's report, published after the Budget yesterday, they sketch out the prospects for real household disposable income per person.

    Before the financial crisis, that was growing by a couple of per cent per year but has "gone right down" to around one per cent across an entire decade, calling it a "very difficult outcome" for people.

    • What is the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR)? The OBR is the UK’s official public finances watchdog. It releases forecasts for the economy and public finances twice a year, alongside the Autumn Budget and Spring Statement.
  13. 'Budget measures will help but people will still feel worse off'published at 07:10 GMT

    Headshot of Helen Miller

    Speaking to BBC Breakfast, Helen Miller, director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies, describes yesterday's Budget as "small overall" but "ram-packed with measures".

    The cost of living package was "always going to be at the heart of this Budget", she continues, and adds that the £100 one-off payment plus other measures "will help people" although she caveats that people haven't yet felt the "full force of winter".

    "We actually think for most families, energy bills [will be] going up by over £400 in comparison to a package of help that's about £130."

    So while it will "definitely help", people are likely to still feel worse off at the end of winter.

    Asked whether the chancellor could have done more, Miller says the war in the Middle East has made the whole country "worse off" and it would never have been possible for him to make us all as well of as we would've been had that not happened.

    She says the government has chosen a "relatively broad" package where they could have chosen to focus on lower income households, adding: "That is just a political choice."

  14. Labour accused of being 'addicted to welfare' - opposition reaction to the Budgetpublished at 07:03 GMT

    Kemi Badenoch laughs in the House of Commons during her Budget response yesterdayImage source, PA Media

    Opposition parties have been reacting to government spending plans unveiled yesterday by John Healey in his first Budget as chancellor.

    The Conservatives have accused Labour of being "addicted to welfare", with Tory leader Kemi Badenoch saying the government had "overspent, overborrowed, overtaxed and [is] drowning in an out-of-control welfare system".

    Reform says the Budget did not address the "ballooning" benefits bill. Leader Nigel Farage said the Budget was full of "little giveaways" but "doesn't overall do very much" and did not offer "anything of any value on defence whatsoever".

    • How much does the UK spend on welfare? At its last forecast in the Spring, the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) estimated that the UK would spend £333bn (or 10.9% of GDP) on welfare this year. This is forecast to reach £407 billion (11.2% of GDP) by 2030-31.

    The Green Party says Labour's Budget lacked ambition, tinkering "round the edges, rather than properly taxing extreme wealth and profits".

    Liberal Democrats leader Ed Davey criticised what he called "stealth tax rises" and argued that weak growth, sluggish growth and squeezed living standards cannot properly be addressed without a "fundamental re-think" of the UK's trading relationship with Europe.

  15. Energy bills will be higher than post-Ukraine invasion, says think tankpublished at 06:52 GMT

    Andy Verity
    BBC Economics correspondent

    UK households will be left paying higher energy bills than during the last energy crisis in 2022, according to analysis of the Budget by the Resolution Foundation.

    The left-leaning think tank said that after newly-announced support, including a £100 energy payment for 20 million households, typical energy bills were nevertheless forecast to be £1,750 in the current financial year.

    That’s higher in real terms (when adjusted for inflation) than during the last energy price shock after the invasion of Ukraine, when net bills were £1,685.

    The Resolution Foundation also said more than £4bn of support with the cost of living is badly targeted - the poorest half of households will gain £158 on average which is just £14 more than the richest.

    That’s partly because the support with energy bills is linked to council tax bands that are based on outdated property valuations from 1991.

  16. Budget key points: A quick guide to Healey's announcementspublished at 06:44 GMT

    Chancellor John Healey holds up the traditional red ministerial box outside No 11 Downing Street ahead of delivering his first Budget on 28 October.Image source, Getty Images

    Energy bills:

    • One-off £100 payment for up to 20 million households in council tax bands A-D in England to help tackle rising energy bills
    • Funding will be allocated to devolved governments, with Wales saying it will match the payment and the Scottish government planning to "replicate" it
    • Standing charges – fixed daily fees customers pay regardless of usage – to be removed from household gas bills in England, Scotland and Wales, with costs added to the unit rate instead

    Taxes:

    • An extra 2% tax on income from savings and property rental from April
    • Amount people can put into tax-free cash ISAs (Individual Savings Accounts) to remain at £20,000 a year, with plans to lower the limit to £12,000 for under-65s scrapped
    • Surcharge banks pay on their profits to rise from 3% to 6% for 15 months, starting in January

    Wages:

    • Legal minimum wage to rise by 3.9% in April
    • Unpaid carers will no longer lose their entire Carer's Allowance if they earn more than £204 a week after tax, with a taper rate introduced instead
    • Parental pay extended to self-employed fathers and parents in same-sex couples

    Housing:

    • New scheme to help first-time buyers in England purchase a home, offering government-backed loans to households earning less than £110,000, or £140,000 inside London
    • A new First-Time Buyer ISA to be introduced from April 2029, to replace the Lifetime ISA and help people save a deposit for their first home
  17. 'Government can never remove completely cost of living pressures' - Healeypublished at 06:42 GMT

    We can bring you some more details now from Healey's interview with Radio 4's Today programme, which will be broadcast in full later at around 08:10 GMT at the top of this page.

    One element he was asked about was the announcement of a one-off £100 energy payment this winter for households in council tax bands A-D - with bills forecast to increase by £276 in January.

    "It will be four in five households, 20 million households - direct £100 payment into their bank accounts and this is a way that we can get the money to these people at the time when they are going to be facing the early winter bills," he says.

    "I do want to be honest with people, government can never remove completely the cost of living pressures that people feel - we can help where we can and that's what I'm doing."

    Asked whether he thought a closer relationship with the EU would be key to economic growth, Healey responded: "You're reflecting the bigger national conversation that the prime minister wants to encourage - that's great."

    Healey says he remains committed to Labour's manifesto pledges, while also saying that "in the meantime...make sure we can get a better deal for Britain".

  18. Chancellor says helping young people not in work can bring down benefits billpublished at 06:32 GMT

    Media caption,

    Healey: 'There will be a reduction in the benefits bill' before election

    Following the measures announced by the chancellor in the House of Commons yesterday, now he has pledged one more - a reduction in the welfare bill ahead of the next general election.

    We don't have many details on this so far - but Healey has said it will be done "in a Labour way".

    We'll hear more from that interview with Radio 4's Today programme later on this morning, for now you can hear some of his comments in the clip above.

  19. Healey promises reduction in welfare bill after Budgetpublished at 06:28 GMT

    Britain's Chancellor of the Exchequer John Healey (L) holds his red dispatch box outside Number 11 Downing StreetImage source, EPA

    It's the morning after Budget day and Chancellor John Healey is already making future pledges on reducing the benefits bill, having been criticised for a lack of details on the issue yesterday.

    In an interview recorded after the Budget, Healey told the BBC it is "simply not good for Britain or progressive to have a bigger and bigger benefits bill", labelling the current system as "unsustainable".

    He ruled out "crude cuts" but more details on his approach are not expected until two major reviews are published next month.

    The Conservatives accused Labour of being "addicted to welfare", while Reform UK said the Budget did not address the "ballooning" benefits bill. Welfare spending is forecast to rise this year by £19bn to £353bn.

    Healey's first Budget as chancellor included various so-called "breathing space" measures including scrapping the standing charge on gas bills in favour of a paid unit rate, and a £100 one-off "Household Energy Payment" for those in council tax bands A to D in England.

    We're resuming our live coverage. We'll catch you up to speed on the measures announced by the chancellor yesterday, before we hear the full details of the chancellor's interview.

  20. Analysis

    A flotilla of small measures as Healey unveils his first Budgetpublished at 19:44 GMT 28 October

    Chris Mason
    Political editor

    This was a Budget I would describe as a flotilla of small measures.

    But, depending on your circumstances, those measures may still feel noticeable - as either a gain or a loss.

    The central challenge for the Chancellor John Healey, which he shares with his recent predecessors, is the public finances are in a mess and so are the personal finances of so, so many households.

    And it is very difficult to do much about one of those things if the other one is in a mess. What we heard today was a cautious acknowledgement of both of these things.

    One critical friend of the government suggested to me this would be a "Mr Sensible Budget" - their hope and expectation that it might be shorn of bells and whistles, but shorn of timebombs too.

    Let’s see. It has allowed Labour’s critics to point to what they see as the vast gulf between the prime minister’s vision and the chancellor’s numbers.

    The Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch said Burnham came to power promising to end 40 years of neoliberalism and "instead, we got 4p off gherkins".

    The central truth tonight is this government’s biggest visible challenges remain: the long term funding of defence, shaking up the benefits system, our relationship with the European Union.

    And, after years of economic turmoil - abroad and at home - the realistic prospect of more to come, squeezing incomes, living standards and, recent years suggest, squeezing patience with government too.

    We're pausing our live coverage now, you can read more in our news story here.