Image source, Getty Images

Stafford Rangers and Cray Wanderers came oh so close to adding their name on the upsets list but they won't be joining Wimborne Town and Oldham Athletic in the second round.

We've still got one more to go as Berkhamsted head to Plymouth Parkway for a tie that will see one team from the Southern League Premier Division South, the seventh division of English football, progress.

We will also have the draw to find out who the weekend's winners will be facing in the second round.

See you tomorrow!

Dom Howson
Co-commentator on BBC Radio Sheffield

You can't question the attitude or the application of the players of both sides.

I thought the tie was played in great spirit, it was really thrilling. It was a throwback and this is what the FA Cup means to people. This might be the highlight of Oldham's season. They should be team pushing at the top end of League Two.

For Wednesday there's a lot of work that Dave Challinor has got to do and I think if he was under any illusion of the size of the task that's facing him... This could end up being a huge blessing in the long run.

They improved as the night wore on but you can't play as passively as they did in the first half when Oldham were the better team.

Dave Challinor said a couple of days ago that the aim is to win. This club has forgotten how to win football matches for 15 to 18 months and it's now one win in seven.

These players should have been busting a gut to impress and show what they're capable of.

That team should have been strong enough to get the result today and they've come up short and that's on the players and we're saying that time and time again at the moment.

That's a concern and a worrying trend and only the team can turn it around.

Image source, Getty Images

Oldham winning goal scorer and academy product Will Sutton speaking to TNT:

"A lad that has come through the academy, I was very excited for the opportunity.

"I don't score many. I didn't know what to do.

"When I made contact initially, I thought I'd put it over. I was just loitering. Right place, right time. I'll be watching that back plenty of times.

"We've got a number of big lads in the team. Even though we backed our ability in open play, we knew that set-pieces would be massive for us in both boxes. It's key and it's won us the game.

"The performances are starting to come and we just need to carry that over in the league now."

Speaking about Micky Mellon's sending off changing the game:

"I'd say so. I'm the wrong person to ask, I didn't realise he got sent off.

"One of the key words we've spoke about is belief. We knew we have the quality to get the win and in those moment it was just pure belief."

We could have witnessed four upsets but we will have to settle for two after comebacks from Grimsby Town and Stockport County.

Read about every thing that happened in our match reports on each game here:

• Stafford Rangers (2) 3-3 (3) Grimsby Town
• Cray Wanderers 2-3 Stockport County
• Wimborne Town 2-0 Crawley Town
• Oldham Athletic 2-1 Sheffield Wednesday

Image source, Getty Images

Oldham Athletic forward Calum Kavanagh speaking to TNT:

"A really enjoyable day and a great victory. All the boys were buzzing.

"We always knew we weren't going to have a lot of the ball, they are a good team. We had to patient and wait for our chances and thankfully, we took them.

"We have got a lot of spirit in this dressing room and I knew we'd come back and fight again. We did that and fortunately we got another goal.

"We've had a good couple of weeks and we are looking to build on that."

On watching his dad Graham at Sheffield Wednesday:

"It was the first club I remember watching him at, I was probably six or seven. But I'm delighted to get on the scoresheet."

Keith Hill
Former Bolton boss on BBC Radio Manchester

Absolutely superb and it was deserved.

In the 90 minutes Oldham were comfortable. Sheffield Wednesday rolled the dice and made their substitutions, they had to. Oldham found it difficult from that point on with the way that Sheffield Wednesday were playing.

In extra-time the game balanced out again. Sheffield Wednesday had a lot of the ball. Oldham found themselves having to defend deeper and deeper but from one free-kick they caused a lot of chaos and it fell for Will Sutton at the far post with an open goal.

Mike Fondop caused physical chaos all game. He deserves man of match for me. A lot of these Oldham players have run themselves into the ground.

Jack Dearden
BBC Radio Manchester commentator

An epic encounter at Boundary Park ends and Oldham Athletic will go into the hat for the next round of the FA Cup.

Image source, Getty Images

Oldham earn their first FA Cup win against Sheffield Wednesday to reach the second round.

The Owls failed to clear a cross across goal and Will Sutton was left unopposed to nod it in.

Wednesday boss Dave Challinor's reign begins with a defeat to a team a league below.

We've reached 120 minutes and there's only one minute for Wednesday to go to penalties.

One last chance.

Di'Shon Bernard has a great connection and throttles at goal, watching it go narrowly wide.

A few inches to the right and we would have had an equaliser.

Max Lowe curls in a cross but it's cut out by Oldham.

Donervon Daniels asks for more from his home fans. Just a few minutes left to victory.

Dom Howson
Co-commentator on BBC Radio Sheffield

I'm looking at the goalkeeper there and I'm thinking he's got to come, he's got to dominate and really take ownership of that situation and he didn't.

It's in the six-yard box and Will Sutton's broke through to the back post and he read the situation well and had the simple task of heading it in.

It was a mess at the back from Wednesday and that's the second time that we've seen that tonight and it's second time that Oldham have punished them.

Jack Dearden
BBC Radio Manchester commentator

It's a header from Will Sutton and he couldn't miss from there.

The Wednesday defence was in tatters and a simple far post header from Sutton might have propelled the Latics into the next stage of the FA Cup.

Wednesday's Callum Slattery puts his laces through a shot but hits it high.

Teenager Will Grainger and 20-year-old Ernie Weaver are on for this final section.

They replace Owls team-mates Jamal Lowe and Yan Valery.

Boundary Park were playing some operatic dramatic music for that little break.

Building up to a great crescendo but that finish looks like it will be from the spot as it stands.

Keith Hill
Former Bolton boss on BBC Radio Manchester

It's becoming a lot more even this side of extra-time.

Towards the end of 90 minutes Sheffield Wednesday were really on top, but it's evened itself out again.

Still no winner despite a push from both sides.

Could we be set for penalties?

Manny Monthe is punished for an obvious pull on an Owls shirt to stop a counter-attack.

Another yellow card. Few of those knocking about now.