Right-winger disappointment but positive overall? Assessing Sunderland's windowpublished at 12:51 BST 2 September

BBC Radio Newcastle's Sunderland commentator Nick Barnes says fans will be disappointed no right winger was signed but, otherwise, the Black Cats have achieved what they set out to in the summer transfer window.
"Overall, it has not been a bad window," he said. "The one thing Sunderland fans will be - I don't know if anxious is the right word, probably disappointed - about is they didn't bring a right winger in. That was the one area everybody felt that there was going to be a nailed-on signing this summer and that hasn't happened.
"For whatever reason, they were also targeting left wingers. Fofana is a left winger. But, they have more or less achieved what they set out to achieve at the end of last season in this window - getting three or four quality players in and not the numbers we saw last season."
Hit play above to hear more on the right-winger situation above, and a more general assessment of the window below. You can listen to both on BBC Sounds.
Meanwhile, former Sunderland midfielder Martin Smith focused on the positive of The Black Cats keeping their top stars.
"It's been massive, just to get that stability," he told BBC Radio Newcastle.
"The way they were going last year, a lot of supporters thought we could lose a Roefs, we could lose a Diarra. Brobbey also went to the World Cup and did well. But, I don't think anybody made any noises to leave, which is a really positive thing.
"I know there was the Granit Xhaka thing, but that got put to bed quite quickly. If he didn't want to be here, he would have made more of a noise and he didn't.
"So it looks like a really settled bunch and it's positive they're adding to it."
What is your assessment of Sunderland's summer transfer business?



















